Print

You have not viewed any products recently.

 

Why you should see the silents, part II

View all posts from this blog

By:Ray Olson | August 06, 2014

Lillian_Gish_in_The_Musketeers_of_Pig_Alley

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

It’s all very well to say, as I do, that you should see the silents because in them you will see every development in film style—except synchronized sound—freshly created and, in most cases, as artfully exploited as they ever have been. But the proof is in the viewing.

What should you see to be convinced the silents are worth seeing?

Here is a list of 79 silents. Though I think they are all artistically significant, they’re also my favorites, which means that some very important films aren’t among them. Birth of a Nation is a milestone, but I don’t greatly like it. (Yes, I think it is offensively racist—race supremacist, to be precise, whereas its source, Thomas Dixon’s pop novel about the real Ku Klux Klan, The Clansman, is race separatist and morally preferable because it is.) Several of Harold Lloyd’s comedies are much liked, but his comic persona grates on me, and not even Safety Last makes my list. A performer’s glamour or acting talent seldom counts that much with me, and though I believe Rudolph Valentino and Douglas Fairbanks were extraordinarily dashing, and Lon Chaney and John Barrymore were great actors, none of their films I’ve seen seem to me first-rate.

I list my favorites chronologically and by genre. The earliest on the whole list is a crime melodrama, so Crime movies come first. The next earliest is a social-problem drama, hence Drama, encompassing all contemporarily set non-comical scenarios, comes next. The other genres, in sequence, are Historical (aka period or costume drama), Documentary and Nonfiction, Comedy, and Fantasy and Adventure. Each film’s listing includes the title in italics and, where helpful, its English translation, also in italics and bracketed, followed by the release date and director in parentheses. Entries including a slash ( / ) list two titles commonly used for the same film. The letters CF or NF after an entry refer to remarks I’ve written on the sites of Classicflix and Netflix, respectively, and signed “—Ray Olson”. “see” after the letters prefaces the title of the rental service’s DVD under which my remarks appear, if it is different from that of the film. “short” at or near the end of an entry denotes a film of less than feature length; good prints of silent shorts can quite often be seen for free on YouTube and other sites. Last in some entries is a term or phrase pointing out one great distinction of the particular entry.

The titles preceded by an asterisk (*) belong to my personal crème de la crème of the silents, movies I consider among the finest ever made, that, as I like to say, justify the invention of the medium.

Crime

The Musketeers of Pig Alley (1912, D. W. Griffith) short; First gangster film

Fantomas (1913-14, Louis Feuillade) CF; Serial

Judex (1916, Feuillade) CF; Serial

Menilmontant (1926, Dmitri Kirsanoff) NF, see Avant-Garde: Experimental; short; A “silent” silent, sans intertitles

Drama

Ingeborg Holm (1913, Victor Sjöström) NF

A Man There Was (1917, Sjöström) NF; On-location filming

The Poor Little Rich Girl (1917, Maurice Tourneur) CF; Set design

The Parson’s Widow (1920, Carl Dreyer)

La roue (1923, Abel Gance) NF; Montage prefiguring Soviet editing

*Greed (1924, Erich von Stroheim)

Wild Oranges (1924, King Vidor) CF

*Visages d’enfants [Faces of Children] (1925, Jacques Feyder)

Gribiche (1926, Feyder) CF

Sunrise (1927, F. W. Murnau)

*The Docks of New York (1928, Josef von Sternberg) NF

Street Angel (1928, Frank Borzage)

White Shadows in the South Seas (1928, W. S. Van Dyke) CF

*Lucky Star (1929, Borzage)

*Old and New / The General Line (1929, Eisenstein) CF, see Landmarks of Early Soviet Film, Disc 1; The acme of Soviet montage

*City Girl (1930, Murnau) NF

*Earth (1930, Alexander Dovzhenko)

*Japanese Girls at the Harbor (1933, Hiroshi Shimizu) NF; Long lap dissolves

*Passing Fancy (1933, Yasujiro Ozu) NF

*Street without End (1934, Mikio Naruse) NF

Historical

Cabiria (1914, Giovanni Pastrone); Massive, expressive sets

*Intolerance (1916, Griffith) NF; Four intertwined plots

Die Nibelungen: Siegfried (1924, Fritz Lang) NF;

Kriemhilds Rache [Kriemhild’s Revenge] (1924, Lang) NF

The Saga of Gösta Berling (1924, Mauritz Stiller) NF

*Battleship Potemkin (1925, S. M. Eisenstein)

Flesh and the Devil (1926, Clarence Brown) CF

The End of St. Petersburg (1927, Vsevolod I. Pudovkin) NF

*Die Liebe der Jeanne Ney [The Love of Jeanne Ney] (1927, G. W. Pabst) NF

*Napoleon (1927, Gance) Anticipates Cinerama, split-screen, “musical” montage, etc.

Wings (1927, William Wellman) NF; Aerial dogfight footage

Four Sons (1928, John Ford) NF  

The Man Who Laughs (1928, Paul Leni) NF

October: Ten Days That Shook the World (1928, Eisenstein)

*La passion de Jeanne d’Arc [The Passion of Joan of Arc] (1928, Dreyer) Maximally expressive close-ups

Storm over Asia (1928, Pudovkin) NF

Arsenal (1929, Dovzhenko)

Die Büchse der Pandora [Pandora’s Box] (1929, G. W. Pabst) NF; Cf. Alban Berg’s Lulu

Documentary and Nonfiction

*In the Land of the Head Hunters / In the Land of the War Canoes (1914, Edward S. Curtis) Kwakiutl ethnography

South (1919, Frank Hurley) NF; Shackleton’s Endurance expedition

Grass (1925, Merian C. Cooper, Ernest B. Schoedsack) NF; Migrant herders of Persia

Chang (1927, Cooper, Schoedsack) NF; Jungle villagers of Thailand

The Man with the Movie Camera (1929, Dziga Vertov); Technically encyclopedic

Regen (1929, Joris Ivens) short

Salt for Svanetia (1930, Mikhail Kolatozov), CF, see Landmarks of Early Soviet Film, Disc 4; short

Comedy

Tillie’s Punctured Romance (1914, Mack Sennett) CF

*Shoulder Arms (1918, Charles Chaplin) short

Why Change Your Wife? (1920, Cecil B. DeMille) NF

The Boat (1921, Buster Keaton, Edward F. Cline) short

The Kid (1921, Chaplin) NF

Le brasier ardent [The Burning Brazier] (1923, Ivan Mozzhukhin) CF

*Our Hospitality (1923, Keaton, John G. Blystone) NF

Entr’acte (1924, René Clair) short; The intermission for Erik Satie’s ballet, Relâche

The Extraordinary Adventures of Mr. West in the Land of the Bolsheviks (1924, Lev Kuleshov) CF, see Landmarks of Early Soviet Film, Disc 1

*The Gold Rush (1925, Chaplin)

His Wooden Wedding (1925, Leo McCarey) short  

The General (1926, Keaton, Clyde Bruckman)

Bed and Sofa (1927, Abram Room) NF

My Best Girl (1927, Sam Taylor) NF

Three’s a Crowd (1927, Harry Langdon) NF

The Cameraman (1928, Keaton, Edward Sedgwick) NF, see TCM Archives: The Buster Keaton Collection

The Chaser (1928, Langdon) NF

The Farmer’s Wife (1928, Alfred Hitchcock) CF    

Steamboat Bill, Jr. (1928, Keaton, Charles Reisner)

You’re Darn Tootin’ (1928, Edgar Kennedy) short

*City Lights (1931, Chaplin)

*I Was Born, but . . . (1932, Ozu)

Modern Times (1936, Chaplin) Includes the most famous instance of film plagiarism

Fantasy and Adventure

After Death (1915, Evgeni Bauer) NF, see Mad Love: The Films of Evgeni Bauer; Cf. Pre-Raphaelite and symbolist painting

*Das Cabinet des Dr. Caligari (1920, Robert Wiene); Abstract set design

Der Golem, wie er in die Welt kam (1920, Paul Wegener) NF

Faust (1926, Murnau) NF

Metropolis (1927, Lang)

Un chien andalou [The Andalusian Dog] (1929, Luis Buñuel, Salvador Dalí) short;   The most surrealist film

Die weisse Hölle vom Piz Palü [The White Hell of Pitz Palu] (1929, Arnold Fanck, Pabst) NF; German “mountain film”; great skiing

Comments

 

 
Rollo
King of Prussia
8/6/2014 05:07 PM
 

  I am glad to see Flesh and the Devil on the list. I think Mysterious Lady, another Garbo film, deserves a mention. I will also suggest one of my favorites, The Last Command with Emil Jennings and William Powell. An important film not on the list, though maybe not one your favorites, Mr. Olson, would be Fritz Langs, Spies, which seemed to be the prototype for many of the spy films to follow. A great post, Mr. Olson. I prefer the silent films to talkies. I was hoping The Artist would have inspired more filmmakers to pick up this art form.

 
 
Joe Johnson
Philadelphia
8/6/2014 07:12 PM
 

  Mr. Ray Olson attacking the birth of a nation? Shame on you!

 
 
Clyde Wilson
Columbia
8/6/2014 08:38 PM
 

  A quick look and I notice only two Garbos? How about the original LAST OF THE MOHICANS and DEERSLAYER. THE WIND? Louise Brooks?

 
 
Ray Olson
St. Paul
8/7/2014 04:16 PM
 

  Rollo--Flesh and the Devil was a great and happy surprise for me. Not only is Garbo magnificent, but director Clarence Brown, who became her favorite to work with, makes every shot count and brings the other principals' performances up to her level, so far up that the ending has genuine, awe-inspiring tragedy about it. Mysterious Lady is, indeed, very good, despite the weakness of her leading man, Conrad Nagel (what, Gilbert was otherwise occupied?), and have you seen The Temptress? These three silents finally convinced me of Garbo's power. It's too bad that her sound films seem to be (I haven't seen them all; not sure I want to) just so many star vehicles. Of the other titles you mention, The Last Command is too bathetic for me, though, of course, Sternberg makes it striking to see all the way; and I'm not an admirer of Lang's spy and crime silents, they bore me.

 
 
Ray Olson
St. Paul
8/7/2014 04:27 PM
 

  Mr. Johnson--On the other hand, I concede and would never deny that Birth is an important film. It just leaves a tacky taste in my mouth. Other Griffiths that didn't make the list but which I quite like are Isn't Life Wonderful?, made in Germany after the Great War and during the hyperinflation of the currency; America, Griffith's attempt to do for the American Revolution what Birth did for the War between the States; Dream Street, at least in part (I like Carol Dempster much better than Lillian Gish, whose replacement she was); and his last, sound film, The Struggle, the sympathetic portrait of an alcoholic, so much that it's on a similar list, still a work in progress, covering the talkies of 1929 as well as the Thirties.

 
 
Print

You have not viewed any products recently.

 

To comment on this article, please find it on the Chronicles Facebook page.