Reviews

The "News: From Moscow

The analysis of dezinformatsia here provided by Richard Shultz and Roy Godson is overloaded with scholarly paraphernalia, ranging from statistical tables of Soviet "overt propaganda themes" to an erratic glossary contain­ing a pompous and unnecessary defini­tion of "forgery" ("Forgery, one of many disinformation techniques, is the use of authentic-looking but false docu­ments and communiques"). Because of a zeal to appear "learned," the authors' style and method of presentation often get in the way of their message. None­theless, Dezinformatsia contains much valuable information about Soviet propaganda methods. Unlike some other writers in this field, Shultz and Godson properly emphasize the central importance of International Informa­tion Departments of the Communist Party's Central Committee rather than focus entirely on the KGB. The book also includes a useful analysis of Soviet manipulation of front groups to further the U.S.S.R.'s foreign policy goals.

If Dezinfonnatsia has a major sub­ stantive flaw, it is its failure to give sufficient attention to Soviet exploita­tion of the non-Soviet press, which is the rhetorical technique that most im­mediately strikes the reader of Soviet publications. In connection with the Korean airliner outrage, for example, the Soviet countercharge of espionage was elaborately buttressed by references to Western sources ranging from the San Francisco Examiner to the New York Times columnist Tom Wicker (who, as one emigre commentator put it, "frequently provides Soviet newspa­pers with extremely useful quotations"). Similarly, a recent Pravda diatribe on "psychological warfare against Afghani­stan" cited three separate non-Soviet sources (the Christian Science Monitor, the USIA, and the "Indian magazine Link") in addition to agencies of the Afghan puppet regime.

When convenient Western sources do not already exist, it is easy enough to create them, and Soviet chutzpah in this area knows no limits. A good illus­tration is the Soviet coverage of the assassination of Grenadian Prime Min­ister Maurice Bishop, who was shot to death by his thuggish comrades of the New Jewel Movement, a party inspired by the Soviet Union and its hirsute marionette, Fidel Castro. Shortly after the American liberation of the island, Pravda suddenly announced that Bish­op had been murdered by the CIA. Pravda's source for this remarkable in­telligence was an obscure English­ language weekly located (of all places) in New Delhi.

According to Pravda (December 20,1983),

The weekly magazine New Wave has published facts incontrovertably demonstrating that the murder of Grenadian Prime Minister Maurice Bishop was carried out by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency on orders from the White House. . . . Based on the testimony of Grenadian eyewitnesses who fled the island after its occupation, the magazine writes that the CIA succeeded in recruiting the chief of the Prime Minister's personal bodyguard and one of his subordinates, who carried out Washington's order and shot Bishop.

However, as a commentator for the Russian-language New York daily Nov­aye Russkoye Slovo noted, not only is New Wave too small to employ any foreign correspondents, but at the time of Bishop's murder Grenada was crawling with Soviet journalists, including a Tass correspondent. (Now the Soviets have issued a postage stamp to com­memorate the "fortieth anniversary of the birth of Maurice Bishop, the Prime Minister of the People's Revolutionary government in Grenada, who met his death in 1983 at the hands of enemies of the Grenadian revolution.")

Though Shultz and Godson fre­quently sacrifice clarity for pedantry, any attempt to expose the Soviet disre­gard for truth can only be welcome.

Dezinformatsia—Active Measures in Soviet Strategy by Richard H. Shultz and Roy Godson; Pergamon Brassey's; Washington.

Henry Mason III

Henry Mason III is an attorney in Chicago

Add a Comment

 

Join the conversation...

You are currently using the BETA version of our article comments feature. You may notice some bugs in submission and user experience. Significant improvements are coming soon!

or

Be the first to comment on this article!

X