The Future of Russia and the West: A Conversation with Elena Chudinova, Part III

View all posts from this blog

By:Eugene Girin | April 24, 2014

[Final part of the interview between Srdja Trifkovic and Elena Chudinova that was started in Part I and Part II.]

ST: Finally, this is something I have asked others and never got a satisfactory answer.  Why is the Russian intelligentsia so fascinated with the West and why does it still have this inferiority complex vis-a-vis the West which we could see even two hundred years ago and throughout the 19th Century?

EC: We were in isolation for seven decades and saw the evil and problems that Soviet rule has brought. And from this, came about the illusion - because a person cannot exist without hope - that wherever there's no communism, everything is right and better. We are still dealing with this post-isolation effect, there is very little sober reasoning.  People were too beaten down by communism and are recovering rather ineptly.

ST: But unfortunately, even after twenty-three years of being kicked around, this sense is still present. Will these people ever learn?

EC: I would say that the people who are still stuck in this, are more so, from my generation [born in the late 1950s and early 1960s] and a bit younger. The youth on the other hand, thinks more realistically and I am very happy to observe our young people who were raised after the collapse of the Soviet Union because they were brought up when Russian Orthodoxy rose up at least a little bit. These young people were raised in a world that became open and they can compare the negatives and positives, they do not have the pious admiration [for all things Western and foreign] that is so typical for my generation. I have great hopes for the post-communist generation of Russians.

ST: So, in a funny way, the generations that grew up under the Soviet Union were better equipped to preserve the spiritual legacy of Old Russia than those growing up in the consumerist, information society?

EC: I would say that everything depends on one's family. I am the granddaughter of a man who was murdered by the Bolsheviks. In our family, there was nothing communistic, not during the Soviet Union and obviously not after. I was not even a member of the Komsomol [communist youth organization]. We had a family of scientists who distanced themselves from Soviet power. Every representative of a White (anti-Bolshevik) family has a great responsibility to educate Russian society and to make sure the ties between the generations will not be lost. This is extremely important and it definitely works. 

I had a stunning experience in Yekaterinburg [where Nicholas II and his family were shot by the Bolsheviks]. When we were marking the 400th jubilee of the House of Romanov and I was invited to one of the commemoration events, a young priest approached me. He brought me my book about the White forces that was written when I was very young during Soviet rule. I could have been imprisoned for writing that book. Now, this book is in its fourth or fifth edition. 

The young priest asked me to inscribe the book for him and said: "You know, I am from a Red family, my great-grandfathers were commissars. So, when I chose to become a priest, it was to atone for their sins". This was a moment of great truth for me. I said to the young priest: "Father, please pray for God's servant Konstantin [Elena Chudinova's grandfather who was murdered by the Bolsheviks -EG]". The fact that I could tell this to a descendant of the Reds means that truth grows and breaks through in our society.

Comments

 

 
Robert Bruce
Riveview
4/25/2014 03:55 AM
 

  Russia can't hold out forever and I don't buy that whole Christian renaissance thing either. Russians are just as materialistic as their American counterparts. Russian Playboy, sexualization of the pop culture, etc. I did a short study abroad back in 1997 that was split between St. Petersburg and Poland. We went around to visit the various Orthodox Churches and were lucky to find even if one person in there was under 40. They might claim to be Orthodox, but like most Americans they really aren't true followers, it is just a cultural distinction.

 
 
Eugene Girin
Forest Hills
4/25/2014 05:14 PM
 

  Mr. Bruce, that was 1997, this is now. If you read Chudinova's comments closely, she differentiates between the older generations and the youth, raised after communism fell. When the relics of the Three Magi came to Russia, tens of thousands of people of all ages stood for hours to venerate them. Dr. Trifkovic also differentiates the wretched state of Russia in the mid 90s with the slow but steady reawakening that's taking place now. And at least the Russian pop "culture" is sexualized in a heterosexual manner, which cannot be said of the West.

 
 
Dan Hayes
r
4/25/2014 06:16 PM
 

  Mr. Girin, the last paragraph's of EC's conversation is quite moving. Your response to Mr. Bruce's comments quite nicely dovetails with it.

 
 
D.D.
Belmont
4/25/2014 07:04 PM
 

  Sadly, Russia's history is one of revolt. The Tsars of the House of Romanov pretty much didn't care a flip for the great majority of people who were peasants or serfs. The organist at my church comes from Kiev. She said that the best time in Russia was related to the Decembrist Revolt of 1825 that produced a generation of literary geniuses. I don't undertand why Ms Chudinova thinks the Romanov dynasty was so great. I have a goal of reading most of Dostoyevsky's stories and novels. I was struck by the poverty and living conditions that seems so common place there that I'm sure were not made up. No wonder the revolts for a better life. Russia's population has decreased. If Elena Chudinova is a "critic of mass non-European immigration" Russia needs to make more babies if she is to grow.

 
 
Eugene Girin
Forest Hills
4/25/2014 10:40 PM
 

  I beg to differ Ms. D. The Decembrists were actually a bunch of radicals who wanted to turn Russia into a Prussia-like secular militaristic state that would've been a bane of traditional Europe. Thankfully, their revolt was crushed. Elena Chudinova's latest novel "December Without Christmas" dealt in great detail with the demonic Decembrists and their rebellion.

 
 
Print

You have not viewed any products recently.

 

To comment on this article, please find it on the Chronicles Facebook page.


UPDATE THIS: Company Name - Phone: (###) ###-####
close (X)