Polemics & Exchanges

Organs, but no Bach

Bobbing about in the eddies of “choice” as we proles of the “Inclusition” are wont to do, how bracing it was to read Christopher Sandford’s piece on Stravinsky (Vital Signs, April)!  Consider this quotation from the composer himself:

The stained-glass artists of Chartres had few colors, and the stained-glass artists of today have hundreds of colors but no Chartres.  Organs, too, have more stops now than ever before, but no Bach.  Not enlarged resources, then, but men and what they “believe.”

Today, we have more “resources” than ever before, yet, without some guiding sense of worth, these “choices” simply reinforce solipsism—as when we dutifully line up to participate in the Menshevik soap opera of national elections and then quack about our freedom and how wonderful it is simply to vote, regardless of whom or what we actually vote for.  Whether in the arts, education, or society, we are meant to revel in the bountiful diversity of “choicemaking” without giving a hoot as to what it means; which, to comment on another excellent article in the April issue, does provide some insight into what Philip Jenkins refers to (“Well, Naturally, We’re Gullible,” Breaking Glass) when discussing the boring...

Join now to access the full article and gain access to other exclusive features.

Get Started

Already a member? Sign in here