Polemics & Exchanges

On Race and Fairness

In “Race and Racism” (Views, November) Tom Landess states that a seismic shift occurred in race relations with Strom Thurmond leading the Dixiecrats out of the Democratic National Convention in 1948.  Now, in 1948, blacks were paying taxes (federal, state, and local).  They saw that money used by politicians to foster second-rate education, housing, and healthcare opportunities.

In thinking about 1948, the question of fairness has to apply.  It’s one thing to think of African-Americans as not of the human race, but it’s quite another to use their tax money to enrich the government’s coffers.

I’m also aware of the argument that paying taxes is always a compromise on how they will be used.  But this would be comparable to paying taxes for a war you disapprove of (take your pick—Vietnam, Iraq) and then sending only blacks to fight it.

—Ted Lederer
Kankakee, IL

Dr. Landess Replies:

I certainly agree that blacks paid taxes during the era of Jim Crow and that their schools and other public facilities were unfairly inferior to those of the whites.  I could name other indignities they suffered under legalized segregation, and indeed I have done so elsewhere.  However,...

Join now to access the full article and gain access to other exclusive features.

Get Started

Already a member? Sign in here