You have not viewed any products recently.


Hillary Blames the Cops

View all posts from this blog

By:Pat Buchanan | May 01, 2015

Had Freddie Gray been robbed, beaten and left to die in the streets of his Baltimore neighborhood, no one would be mourning him today.

No one would be marching for Freddie. No one would be using Freddie as the new poster child of "Black Lives Matter!"

No one would care, three weeks later, but his family and friends.

It was the manner of his death, suffering a fractured spine in police custody, that makes Freddie matter. For he can now be credibly cast in the victim's role in the great new narrative against America—that ours is a society of unequal justice where racist cops routinely brutalize black men and boys and are rarely called to account.

In this narrative, the liberal is always the hero.

Hillary Clinton knows the narrative by heart and has rushed forward to cast herself as the champion of black America.

As The Washington Times reports, Hillary declared Wednesday she would help to end a "pattern" of cops killing black men.

"There is something wrong when a third of all black men face the prospect of prison during their lifetimes. And an estimated 1.5 million black men are 'missing' from their families and communities because of incarceration and premature death. . . .

"My heart beaks for these young men and their families. We have to come to terms with some hard truths about race and justice in America."

We certainly do, Hillary.

She specifically mentioned Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown.

But Trayvon died when he was shot sitting on top of and beating senseless a neighborhood watch guy, "martial arts style," and banging his head on the sidewalk as he screamed for help.

Michael Brown died of gunshot wounds when, after knocking over a convenience store and throttling the clerk in Ferguson, Missouri, he tried to wrestle a gun from a cop, and, told to halt, charged the officer.

This latest great narrative against America—that the men in blue are a threat to us all, especially black America, rather than the last line of society's defense from its criminal class—is but another big lie, rooted in a tiny truth.

Yes, some black men and boys are killed every year in clashes with cops. And, yes, blacks are incarcerated in far greater proportions and suffer, on average, more early deaths. But who is killing them?

When black men and boys are shot to death, overwhelmingly, it is by other black men and boys. Their premature deaths are due to the violent culture in their own communities, not rampaging white cops.

As for incarcerations, every imprisoned male has confessed to or been convicted of a crime. And many of the drug charges for which blacks are in prison were a result of their being allowed to plea bargain to a lesser offense.

Freddie Gray had a rap sheet of a dozen arrests.

Fifty years ago, Lyndon Johnson declared at Howard University, "We seek . . . not just equality as a right and a theory but equality as a fact and equality as a result."

In pursuit of equality of result there began one of the most massive transfers of wealth in all history. Trillions of tax dollars were plunged into programs of social uplift. The results in black America?

Where the illegitimacy rate was 23 percent in 1965, it is 72 percent now, and the gap between black and white test scores endures. In the black community, the dropout rate, crime rate, drug use rate and incarceration rate are now far higher now than in 1965.

And one notices something else in America. The lawns are being mowed, potholes filled, ditches dug, fast-food served, dishes washed and buildings cleaned increasingly by folks who are newcomers. It is they who are, in Jesse Jackson's phrase, "movin' on up."

Looking back to when LBJ's Great Society was launched, and the moral, social and cultural revolution of the 1960s began, what has liberal ideology done for black America?

Their work ethic has been eviscerated by an endless flow of social welfare benefits. Those benefits have often removed the incentive to find or hold a job, and the necessity to have a breadwinner, a father in the home.

The social and cultural revolution of the 1960s undermined the black churches and depopulated them of their young.

The expulsion of the Bible and of all religious and moral instruction from public schools left black children defenseless against the lure of the lifestyles of gang leaders and rap singers.

The conscience- and character-forming institutions that inculcated the beliefs and values that sustained black families through the Depression, the war and the 1950s have collapsed.

Result: Many black neighborhoods are unsafe for those who live there.

Hillary's answer: "It's time to end the era of incarceration in America." But how will returning scores of thousands of convicts to their home communities make them safer—not to mention ours?

Given how it all worked out, are we really ready for Hillary and another giant leap forward into Great Society liberalism?


Patrick J. Buchanan is the author of the new book The Greatest Comeback: How Richard Nixon Rose From Defeat to Create the New Majority. To find out more about Patrick Buchanan and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Web page at




Harry Heller
San Francisco
5/2/2015 12:30 AM

  Black racial nationalists are trying to inject affirmative action into criminal arrest procedures. They want white cops to have to utilize a higher level of awareness and "kid gloves" when apprehending black criminals, all on threat of "no justice, no peace". Of course, God forbid Buchanan should ever tell the WHOLE truth about this sorry state of affairs: to wit, that this is what happens when a superior race is forced to integrate with an inferior one. The problem is only indirectly white liberalism. The real problem is exactly as the white nationalist Right has always argued: racial diversity leads to racial tensions and general discord, while coercively forcing whites to territorially integrate with blacks has dramatically lowered the quality of civilized life for whites. Perhaps Chronicles should FINALLY devote an issue to the subject of the "costs of diversity"? Anyway, America is cleaving, and the future of the Right will belong to the Racial Right. My suggestion is that paleocons make themselves useful by doing some integration of their own, creating bridges between classical conservatism and racial nationalism. Otherwise, the Christian traditionalist cause will only render itself ever more irrelevant to the shaping of onrushing events.

Los Angeles
5/2/2015 02:13 AM

  I know the Republicans don't have many fans around here, but if we are entering a new era of urban unrest, I'd rather have a Republican in charge, than Hillary who will make endless excuses for the urban terrorists.

Bos Bob
Boston MA
5/2/2015 02:44 AM

  Treachery and cowardice on the pedestal of positive energy knows no bounds in America, and American ruling class have no class or shame, or they are zombies - what difference does it make.

Clyde Wilson
Columbia, SC
5/2/2015 01:02 PM

  Every one of the deplorable policies: Republican congressman abetted their passage and postured morally about them. Republican Presidents institutionalised and expanded them (Nixon, Ford, the sainted Reagan, Bush major and minor. We might even say Eisenhower presided over the beginning of the revolution ). Republican Supreme Court Justices validated them. I can't get too mad at Hillary.

Ray Olson
St. Paul
5/4/2015 01:59 PM

  Pretty shabby, Mr. Buchanan. "Hilary blames the cops", your headline screams. But nowhere in your column do you quote her saying any such thing. (I think she's too canny a politician to do that.) "[T]hat the men in blue are a threat to us all, especially black America, rather than the last line of society's defense from its criminal class—is but another big lie, rooted in a tiny truth", you write, but how successful is that big lie, and with whom? I submit that it isn't very widely believed at all, perhaps only by those in places like Ferguson, Missouri, and the "high-crime" areas of Baltimore, New York City, etc. "Freddie Gray had a rap sheet of a dozen arrests", you write, as if that expunged the questionable circumstances of his arrest and fatal injuries, as if, indeed, it justified his death. You attempt to divert attention from those questionable circumstances by blaming black American culture for degeneracy and the high rate of incarceration to which it has led. I don't disagree with you about those matters; the degeneracy and the high incarceration rate are real. But they don't explain Freddie Gray's death, and they don't answer criticisms of the kind of policing black-majority communities receive and of the disproportionate sentencing and penalizing of black offenders--an ostensibly "liberal" critique, which is probably why you pooh-pooh them, though as I think you are well aware, liberal social engineering, from the New Deal on, is much to blame for the ills those critiques target.


You have not viewed any products recently.


To comment on this article, please find it on the Chronicles Facebook page.