Hanging Rudy Out to Dry

View all posts from this blog

By:Pat Buchanan | February 24, 2015

Back in 1987, this writer was invited by friends to advise them on a press conference they had called to oppose President Reagan's signing of an INF treaty to remove all nuclear missiles from Europe.

My advice: Deplore the treaty; do not attack the president.

The next day, Howard Phillips declared that Ronald Reagan had become a "useful idiot for Soviet propaganda."

Howie captured the headlines, as did Rudy Giuliani after that dinner at 21 Club for Gov. Scott Walker, where the mayor spontaneously rose to declaim, "I know this is a horrible thing to say, but I do not believe that the president loves America. . . . He wasn't brought up the way you were brought up and I was brought up, through love of his country."

The next day, Rudy doubled down, bringing up Obama's old ties to socialists and communists: Stalinist Frank Marshall Davis, radical Saul Alinsky, 1970s bomber Bill Ayers, Rev. Jeremiah Wright.

Rudy could not understand why at the National Prayer Breakfast the president launched an attack on the Crusades and the Inquisition, done "in the name of Christ." The mayor could not understand why Obama had trouble identifying and naming ISIS as radical Islamic terrorists.

Though this writer heard several radio talk show hosts Friday cheer Rudy on, Republicans swiftly declared that Obama's love for America must not be questioned. Urged to put space between themselves and Rudy, most Republican leaders swiftly did.

The consultant class' advice was near unanimous: Cut Rudy loose.

Sensing retreat, the left pursued. And it is not letting go. They still demand to know why Walker did not renounce Rudy and whether he believes Obama is a Christian. For weeks the governor has been bedeviled for refusing to say in London if he believes in evolution.

Walker's initial response to whether he thought Obama was a Christian was, "I don't know. . . . To me this is a classic example of why people hate Washington, and, increasingly, they dislike the press."

Yet, Walker's spokesperson hastily issued this corrective statement, "Of course the governor thinks the president is a Christian."

Monday, Rudy walked back his remark that Obama does not love America, writing in the Wall Street Journal, "I didn't intend to question President Obama's motives or the content of his heart."

The Republican rout was complete.

While this, too, shall pass away, what it reveals is the balance of power in the culture war and which side has the whip hand. And what it portends is a drive by the left to pull the GOP back onto the terrain of moral and social issues where its candidates are, or can be portrayed, as out of step with modernity.

Lately, this writer heard a political analyst say that if the GOP platform opposes same-sex marriage, the party can write off California and its 55 electoral votes. Which may be true. Such has been the cultural and moral shift in America in just a few years.

Yet if the party is true to its past platforms and professed convictions, how can it endorse or equivocate on same-sex marriage?

As for whether one believes in Darwinian evolution, it is neither an inconsequential nor illegitimate question. For where one stands on biblical truth, natural law, a creator and intelligent design is a strong if not absolute indicator of where one comes down on abortion, same-sex marriage, assisted suicide, euthanasia and legalized narcotics.

To traditionalists, the de-Christianized and secularized character of American society is of greater concern than whose flag flies over Sebastopol.

And if the GOP visibly retreats or takes a stand of studied neutrality on these issues, it will lose the enthusiasm of the most ardent of its admirers. And the party can't afford that.

Democrats and their media allies may be expected to elevate the social issues, both because they sever the GOP from the cultural-media mainstream, and they drive a wedge into the party base between economic and social conservatives.

One imagines those conservatives gathered at Club 21 were more interested in hearing how a President Walker would cut corporate and capital gains taxes than how soon Roe v. Wade could be overturned.

Since the Republican victory in November, it has not been a good quarter for the GOP. Obama, repudiated, seems liberated.

Ignoring GOP protests, he issued an executive amnesty for five million illegal immigrants. He promises to veto the Keystone XL pipeline. He taunted the GOP in his State of the Union. He is back to 50 percent approval in the polls.

The economy added 1 million jobs in three months. The Dow Jones Friday hit a record high. Senate Democrats are happily filibustering to death the House bill to defund amnesty. And if the Department of Homeland Security has to shut down for lack of funds, Obama and his media allies will see to it the GOP is blamed.

And the national rollouts of the Bush III and Walker campaigns have shown that neither is ready for prime time.


Patrick J. Buchanan is the author of the new book The Greatest Comeback: How Richard Nixon Rose From Defeat to Create the New Majority. To find out more about Patrick Buchanan and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Web page at www.creators.com.




Bryan Fox
2/24/2015 03:35 PM

  Nothing Giuliani said was false. The GOP is composed of cowards and odious charlatans. There is a strong strain of traditionalist's ignored by the so called media, alienated by the Republicans. While the media lives outside of life's reality to portray modernity as a false mainstream. The economy added 1 million jobs in three months, do you really believe that?

Ray Olson
St. Paul
2/24/2015 03:37 PM

  Good news from Mr. Buchanan--the Republican Party is on the ropes! I hope and pray its fortunes will only further decline. Perhaps one of the reasons they will is that a hefty majority of Republican voters supports gay marriage, doesn't want Roe v. Wade overturned, and regards the anti-Darwinians as a bunch of crude, stupid, bullying yahoos bent on destroying public education. The finest Christian and the finest Republican voter I have ever known, my father, died before gay marriage was more than a blip on the political horizon, but he told me more than once that the rabid anti-abortion crowd and the anti-evolutionists were bad for the party. I agreed with him then and I agree with him still, though in the meantime I've abandoned all hope for the Republican Party.

Robert M. Peters
Coushatta, Louisiana
2/24/2015 05:51 PM

  In my attempt to comment on this article, I feel no little like Brer Rabbit about to hit the tar baby, although, unlike Brer Rabbit, I know that it is a tar baby. I sense Dr. Fleming, the Brer Fox of these fora, laying low, with a bit of a grin to see what fool ventures there. The talk show host, Mike Church, seemingly very much in the conservative camp, very quickly denounced Rudy's words as scandalous as to sin citing passages which he was aware of from the Summa by St. Thomas, while leveling heavy criticism toward Obama, both against his words and his deeds, adding, however, that one, save God, could not truly know the heart of a man. I do note that Rudy being a prosecuting attorney has that in common with our Adversary. Mr. Church, however, was not motivated in his critique of Rudy by political or politically correct considerations. I am, however, not sure what Rudy's motives were: a genuine concern for the condition of a man's heart or the punch line to sealing a political deal over supper. My daddy told me two things about judging: before judging one should have repented of one's on sins; and, sometimes, since Holy Writ says "by their fruits shall ye know them," one does not have to be a judge; one simply functions as a fruit inspector: foul fruit fresh from the tree betrays a rotten tree. Based on what I think I know about Obama, with large gaps of ignorance on my part, I am willing to stipulate that he is an citizen of the United States as citizenship is currently determined; but I see little in what I know about him and what I know of his actions that would allow me to conclude that he is an American. It seems that the America of kith and kin, of home and hearth, of land and toil is alien to him. It is hard indeed to love an alien, although one may use aliens as objects of one's machinations. Please, please, please, don't throw me in that briar patch!

frank brownlow
2/25/2015 01:08 AM

  RG told an obvious truth to a nation of liars. Not much more to be said.

San Antonio
2/25/2015 01:31 AM

  The Republican Party has been completely rotten since Bush 1. While there were a few minor pockets of conservatism in the Democratic Party it has been bad since Al Smith walked out of their convention back in 1936. So I still don't get what all the fuss is about anyway. I am now convinced that a return to monarchy is the only hope for the west although I will not hold my breath on that happening. Ray when is your next movie post coming? Did you see one called Monsieur Vincent (1947) yet? Saint Vincent DePaul has never been one of my favorites, but what a movie! Excellent film. In addition, I would add Brian De Palma's body of work to the mounting evidence that the film school generation is what destroyed Hollywood. With the exception of The Untouchables which I like, his films offer nothing of value. He copied all of Hitchcock's techniques, but substituted rotten characters and mucho blood to make some of the most putrid stuff on film. Only The Untouchables had any sympathetic characters in it. I watched it recently and I had not seen it since it came out. After 28 years it holds up surprisingly well.


You have not viewed any products recently.


To comment on this article, please find it on the Chronicles Facebook page.

UPDATE THIS: Company Name - Phone: (###) ###-####
close (X)