Image Credit: 

above: Apotheosis of Washington E Pluribus Unum [Image by: Farragutful / CC BY-SA 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons, resized]


Stress Test of a Straining Superpower

How great a burden can even an unrivaled superpower carry before it buckles and breaks? We may be about to find out.

Rome was the superpower of its time, ruling for centuries almost the entirety of what was then called the civilized world. 

Great Britain was a superpower of its day, but she bled, bankrupted, and broke herself in the Thirty Years War of the West from 1914-1945. By Winston Churchill's death in 1965, the empire had vanished, and Britain was being invaded by a stream of migrants from its former colonies.           

America was the real superpower of the 20th century and became sole claimant to that title with the collapse of the Soviet Union between 1989 and 1991, an event Vladimir Putin called "the greatest geopolitical tragedy of the 20th century." Has America's turn come? Is America breaking under the burdens it has lately assumed and is attempting to carry?           

Today, at the presidential library of Richard Nixon, who ushered Mao's China onto the world stage, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is laying out a strategy of containment and confrontation of a China that is far more the equal of the USA than was the USSR. Writes Hudson's Institute's Arthur Herman: "In the 1960s, manufacturing made up 25 percent of U.S. gross domestic product. It's barely 11 percent today. More than five million American manufacturing jobs have been lost since 2000."          

China controls the production of 97 percent of the antibiotics upon which the lives of millions of Americans depend. She provides critical components in the production chains of U.S. weapons systems. Beijing commands more warships than the U.S. Navy and holds a trillion dollars in U.S. debt. Moscow never had this kind of hold on us.       

Writes Herman: "Since 2000, America's defense industry has shed more than 20,000 U.S.-based manufacturing companies. As the work those companies once did domestically has shifted overseas, much of it has gone to China. From rare-earth metals and permanent magnets to high-end electronic components and printed circuit boards, the Pentagon has slowly become dependent on Chinese industrial output. Asia produces 90 percent of the world's circuit boards—more than half of them in China. The U.S. share of global circuit-board production has fallen to 5 percent."           

Decoupling from China and re-industrializing America would be an immense undertaking. But unless and until we do it, we remain vulnerable.         

Another decades-long struggle, this time with China, like the Cold War that consumed so much of our attention and wealth from the 1940s to 1991, is not the only challenge America faces.           

Through NATO, the U.S. is still the principal protector of almost 30 European nations. And despite Donald Trump's promise to end our forever wars, 8,500 U.S. troops remain in Afghanistan, 5,000 in Iraq, hundreds in Syria, thousands more in Kuwait and Bahrain.  

There are other huge new claims on America's time, attention, and resources. Some 145,000 Americans have perished in five months of the coronavirus pandemic, more U.S. dead than all the Americans soldiers lost in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan. A thousand Americans are dying every day, a higher daily death toll than in World War II and the Civil War combined.        

The U.S. economy has been thrust into something approaching a second Depression. The 2020 deficit runs into the trillions of dollars. Our national debt is now far larger than our GDP and soaring. Tens of millions are unemployed. And the shutdowns are beginning anew.          

From the protests, riots, rampages, and statue-smashing of the last two months, it is apparent that millions of Americans detest our history and heroes. Though nowhere in recorded time have 42 million people of African descent achieved the measures of freedom and prosperity they have in the USA, we are daily admonished that ours is a rotten and sick society whose every institution is shot through with "systemic racism." The racial divisions are almost as ugly as during the riots of the 1960s in Harlem, Watts, Newark, and 100 cities that exploded after the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King. 

In the numbers of citizens now shot and killed every week, great American cities such as Baltimore, St. Louis, Detroit, and Chicago are looking more like Baghdad.

The Democratic Party is promising to take up the issue of racial reparations for our original sin of slavery. The first order of business, we are told, is ending inequality—of income, wealth, educational attainment, and health care. The racial disparity in police arrests, prosecutions, incarcerations, and school expulsions, must end. But if the trillions we have spent to address these inequalities since the Great Society days have failed to make greater progress, why should we believe that we even know how to succeed, absent the imposition of a rigid socialist egalitarianism of results?

The Old Republic is facing a stress test unlike any it has known since the Union was threatened with dissolution in the Civil War.

Patrick J. Buchanan

Patrick J. Buchanan

Patrick J. Buchanan is the author of Nixon’s White House Wars: The Battles That Made and Broke a President and Divided America Forever. To find out more about Patrick Buchanan and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators website at www.creators.com.

Add a Comment


Join the conversation...

You are currently using the BETA version of our article comments feature. You may notice some bugs in submission and user experience. Significant improvements are coming soon!


Account Photo
Robert Smith
Why have so so many people now use the war between the states as a reason for or condition of some current condition. To save face, Mr. Lincoln sent over one million Americans, both military and civilians, to their death. No civil war, no one trying to overthrow a country or a physical capital. Until slavery was used to coerce the North into staying the course, the war could have ended 2 1/2 years earlier. As Jeff Davis said, “We just want to be left alone”. If any reparations are due or owed to anyone, it would be to the entire Southern descendants who were killed or starved or property destroyed by fellow Americans when the northern invaded the south. If secession was not legal, then they attacted innocent civilians, Americans. You also never hear that the champion of the abolitionist was at his death, working on a way to send the blacks back to Africa because he said we could not live together as one people with whites. Slavery would have ended in probably 10 years without the deaths of so many.


The Confederacy did not want to leave Mexico and Central America alone. They wanted to incorporate them as new slave states. If you like plantations with slaves then you must like the new drug plantations the cartels run in Mexico now.