Image Credit: 

[Image from: Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons]


Is America Becoming a Failed State?

Suddenly, Sunday, a riveting report came over cable news: The U.S. embassy was urging all Americans to "leave Afghanistan as soon as possible." Message: Get out while you can. Adding urgency was news that three northern provincial capitals, including Kunduz city, had fallen to the Taliban, making it five provincial capitals overrun since Friday. The huge investment in blood and treasure by the United States over two decades to remake Afghanistan appears about to be wiped out, whole and entire, and we appear about to sustain our worst diplomatic and political defeat since the fall of Saigon.

Not once in this century has the U.S. decisively won one of the wars it launched—in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, or Libya. And the sole superpower status we enjoyed as the 21st century began is gone with the wind. Yet America's hawks are urging us to give a new war guarantee to Taiwan, should Beijing exercise its claim, though former President Richard Nixon and former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger assented in 1972 that Taiwan is "a part of China."

Before we issue any war guarantee to Taipei, we might consider the Pentagon's evaluation of the results of a recent war game in which the U.S. confronted China over Taiwan. How did it go? Says vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. John Hyten, "Without overstating the issue, it failed miserably.”

An aggressive red team that had been studying the United States for the last 20 years just ran rings around us. ... They knew exactly what we were going to do before we did it, and they took advantage of it.

Are we Americans prepared, in any way, for an air-sea-and-missile war in Southeast Asia and the Western Pacific over islands they claim as their historic national territory, but we have never claimed as ours?

Here at home, the COVID-19 pandemic, now in a fourth wave, is infecting 100,000 Americans every day, with hospitalizations rising commensurately. For that third of a nation still unvaccinated, the delta variant is a potential death sentence. Despite this medical crisis that is common to us all, our political divide is manifesting itself in savage battles over vaccinations, masks, and mandates. And while COVID-19 continues to infect, hospitalize, and kill, scores of thousands of Americans are being annually lost to drug overdoses and opioids.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 93,000 overdose deaths occurred across the country in 2020, and 3 in 4 fatal overdoses can be attributed to opioids. More Americans are dying yearly from overdoses and opioids than all the Americans dead during the war in Vietnam. 

The U.S. trade deficit numbers just came in for June, where the deficit in goods alone increased to $91 billion for the month. This translates into $1 trillion a year. The largest component of that trade deficit is with China—an extraordinary level of U.S. dependency on a foreign nation for the vital necessities of its national life, let alone on an adversary like China.

On our southern border, an invasion of our country is taking place. Every month President Joe Biden has been in office, illegal border crossings have increased. In June, Border Patrol recorded 178,000 border arrests—a 571 percent jump from June 2020. Border arrests have already reached their highest since 2000 and are on track to reach 1.8 million this year. Biden is failing in his first constitutional duty—to defend the United States from foreign invasion. We Americans no longer decide who comes into our national home and whom we shall adopt as new citizens. Others decide, others determine our future, for us. 

We defend the borders of scores of nations; we cannot, or Biden will not, defend our own. And, as former President Ronald Reagan reminded us, a country that can't or won't defend its borders isn't really a country anymore.

In our great cities, public shootings and killings have begun to exceed those of previous years. Police, under attack and abuse from the elites and people they protect, are resigning and retiring in record numbers.

Consider. America is unable to win the wars she chooses to fight. She cannot or will not control and defend her borders from a mass migrant invasion. She cannot halt an outbreak of criminality and killing in her great cities. She has not run a trade surplus in four decades. Her dependency upon foreign producers is unprecedented. And her budget deficits continue to break records every year—as does her soaring national debt. Is that not the description of a failed or failing state?

Asked by a despondent young friend if the defeat at Saratoga and potential loss of the American colonies meant the ruin of Britain, Adam Smith assured him, "There is a great deal of ruin in a nation." Britain would go on from the loss of her 13 colonies to create the greatest empire since Rome.

Yet if there is "a great deal of ruin in a nation," we Americans certainly appear to be testing those limits.


Patrick J. Buchanan

Patrick J. Buchanan

Patrick J. Buchanan is the author of Nixon’s White House Wars: The Battles That Made and Broke a President and Divided America Forever. To find out more about Patrick Buchanan and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators website at www.creators.com.

Add a Comment


Join the conversation...

You are currently using the BETA version of our article comments feature. You may notice some bugs in submission and user experience. Significant improvements are coming soon!


Dear Mr. Buchanan, ¶ In addition to the various indications of a failing state that you mention, I would add another: the inability of the political establishment and the nation to formulate a well-reasoned coherent plan as to what should be done. Can we not think about the possibility of a coherent plan, a politically intelligent ideological synthesis of the left and the right, capable of uniting the people in confronting the decline of the nation? For the good of the country? ⁋ Charles McKelvey, Professor Emeritus, Presbyterian College, Clinton, South Carolina


Account Photo
America" has been a failed state since its inception. It is not and has never been a democracy though most believe it is one. It began with the corrupt and continued wiping out of 30 to 40 million natives. It has seen many wars right from its inception and I will not count all the murderous 'Indian' wars as there are so many. One of its big wars was the one with Spain as the US stole the land governed by Spain at a time when Spain had troubles at home. "Men, women, Children were murdered in the take over of Florida. Others sent off to much less 'greener' pastures. The US has been continually, almost at war somewhere, but not always with US military but often backing para-paramilitaries as it still does today. Afghanistan is one. Today the US has pulled out of Afghanistan but it had been in Afghanistan well previous to this war. The US real beginning in Afghanistan was in 1979 with the crime of setting up Russia to be broken by a long war; economically speaking; think Brzezinski. The biggest con was not that of the Russia but of the Afghani peoples who thought they were kicking out the Russians with the backing of CIA Intel. A lie! The Afghan's were used to try break the Russia economy so the war went on and on. Osama was the chosen leader be the US of the Mujahedin. They were tricked and Osama bin Laden was very angry by the waste of lives initiated by US lies. So, if Osama did engineer the WTC collapse (which I doubt) he had very good reasons to be that angry with a lying USA! This is the essence of the US and its failure as a moral country. And this has happened in so many countries: Iran - 1953 Chile - 1973 Grenada Venezuela El Salvador and on and on. So yes. The US has failed miserably and is a rogue country.


I agree we should not protect the world but If the plan is to abandon Taiwan we should sell Taipei its own nukes Our deal with Taiwan and Japan has already been they did not need their own nukes since we would protect them. Our nukes have stopped a pacific war for last 80 years If Taiwan and Japan had their own nukes would not attack


Account Photo
The spreading of nukes is basically insane. The US ought to quit screwing with our world. US actions are by far more disastrous than helpful. Just look at the horrors created by US interference!