When I delivered Liberty: The God That Failed into the hands of my publisher, I did so with no little trepidation. Supported entirely by Protestant, secular academic, and other non-Catholic sources, including the work of numerous historians of the first rank, its detailed, 700-page counternarrative of the rise and fall of what the moderns call Liberty was carefully designed to avoid any accusation of Catholic special pleading. Yet I knew that reactions to the book would fall basically into two categories: on the one hand, careful consideration of its amply supported contentions by those who would be surprised, as I was, by the truths hidden by the golden legends that make up the story political modernity tells about itself; and, on the other hand, angry rejection and gratuitous invective on the part of those who would not take the time to give the work a careful and dispassionate reading. Clyde Wilson, I am sorry to say, falls into the latter category. And I say with this great respect for his work and for Chronicles, one of America’s premiere intellectual journals. Indeed, I was honored to see R. Cort Kirkwood’s favorable review (“Liberty: The God With Feet of Clay,” December 2013) of Liberty in these pages.
Dr. Wilson’s letter to the editor (“
Join now to access the full article and gain access to other exclusive features.
Already a member? Sign in here